Blog Viewer

NEWS: No Benefit to IV Sodium Bicarbonate or Acetylcysteine for Prevention of Contrast-Associated Acute Kidney Injury in High-Risk Patients: The PRESERVE Trial

By Currents Editor posted 04-13-2018 14:40


Read the article.

Listen to the podcast.

Author: Weisbord, SD, Gallagher M, Jneid H, et al. “Outcomes after angiography with sodium bicarbonate and acetylcysteine.” NEJM 2018; 378(7): 603-614

Reviewed by: Sara Stern-Nezer, MD, MPH, Assistant Clinical Professor, University of California, Irvine


This study was a multi-site, international double-blind, placebo and drug-controlled RCT done between 2013 and 2017.  Patients with decreased GFR (15-44.9 for all patients and 45-59.9 among those with DM) were enrolled and randomized in a 2x2 factorial design to receive either IV 1.26% sodium bicarbonate or IV 0.9% sodium chloride and oral acetylcysteine (NAC) or placebo capsules.  Patients requiring emergent angiogram were excluded.  Patients received IV fluids at 1-3ml/kg before angiography, 1-1.5ml/kg during and 1-3ml/kg after angiography.  Fluids were capped at a weight of 125kg to limit excessive fluids to obese patients.  Primary end points were death, need for dialysis and persistent increase of 50% or more from baseline in serum creatinine 90-104 days after angiography.  Secondary end points included AKI (defined as increase of serum creatinine of at least 25% from baseline 3-5 days post-angiography), dialysis by 90 days, hospitalization for any cause within 90 days or death.  Analysis was done using intention-to-treat analysis.


A total of 5177 patients underwent randomization with withdrawal of 184, of which most were excluded as they did not ultimately undergo angiography; 90% of included patients underwent coronary angiography.  Median age was around 70 in all groups and there was no significant difference between groups in any demographic or procedural factor. The median volume of IV fluids was 344 ml before [IQR 274-444], 114ml [IQR 74-170] during and 570ml [IQR 472-670] after angiography.  Primary end point was reached in 4.4% vs 4.7% in the sodium bicarbonate vs normal saline group and 4.6% vs 4.5% in the NAC vs placebo group.  There was similarly no difference in AKI in either group during admission or at 90 days.  The study was stopped early as preplanned interim analysis showed no difference in primary endpoint between groups. 


The PRESERVE trial shows no benefit of administration of IV sodium bicarbonate nor NAC to prevent contrast-induced acute kidney injury.  This study is the largest randomized trial to look at IV sodium bicarbonate and acetylcysteine for prevention of contrast-induced nephropathy; it follows the Acetylcysteine for Contrast-induced Nephropathy Trial (ACT) which enrolled 2308 patients; unlike the ACT trial, this study was limited to patients with lower GFR who are at higher risk for AKI after contrast administration. The one caveat may be that the median volume of contrast material was 85; this volume was relatively small as only 28-29% in each group underwent intervention. It may be that there is some potential benefit in patients undergoing larger volumes of contrast, however, the data to date shows no beneficial effect in this high risk population. #LiteratureWatch #SaraStern-Nezer

Richard Choi, DO Please note this opinion piece reflects the views of the author and does not necessarily reflect the position of ChristianaCare.   The recent wave of increased social and racial injustice awareness as well as the significant increase in anti-Asian hate crimes 1 have had me ...
Lindner A, Rass V, Ianosi BA, et al. The Importance of PbtO2 Probe Location for Data Interpretation in Patients with Intracerebral Hemorrhage. Neurocritical Care . 2020 Sep 11:1-0.  Reviewed by Wazim Mohamed, MD Read the Article Background : Secondary brain injury after spontaneous intracerebral ...
By Wade Smith, MD, PhD, FNCS COVID-19 Vaccinations: Hope Is on the Horizon Dear NCS Members, As hopeful news about COVID-19 vaccines spreads nationwide, we can start looking forward to a safe return to our regular lives. Rates of hospitalizations have fallen across the United States. All ...